Best Commodity Brokers 2021

Getting into commodities trading is great if you’re an advanced trader looking to diversify your portfolio. 

If you’re a beginner, trading commodities can be a good introduction to the world of market exchange. 

In our review, we give you a list of the best Commodity Brokers in 2021 and detailed information about what they are, and how to choose which one is best for you.

Best Commodity Trading Platforms 2021

When compiling this list we considered the fee structures, trading platforms, and research and educational content offered by the brokers. 

Interactive Brokers

Interactive brokers have been tailor-made for advanced, active traders worldwide. 

Their trading platform is great for intermediate traders. 

Interactive Brokers is an incredibly competitive broker that offers a robust range of asset classes available in 125 markets globally.  Their market access is unparalleled and they offer a wide variety of tools to meet every need you could have. 

Interactive Brokers Logo
PROS
CONS
Amazing smart order router
Streaming data is available on one device at a time
Robust range of asset classes available 
The smart order router is not available for IBKR Lite customers
Mutual Fund Replicator is available 
Not suitable for inactive or casual traders 

eToro

Founded in 2007, eToro is regulated in two tier-1 jurisdictions and one tier-2 jurisdiction. This makes it one of the safest brokers when trading CFDs or forex. 

This platform is great if you want to invest in social copy trading or cryptocurrencies. 

eToro is one of our favorite platforms because its web-based platform and mobile app are user-friendly. Their platforms are a good option for casual traders and beginners. 

A downside to eToro is that they tend to have higher fees when trading forex and CFDs so this is something to keep in mind. Their research material is also limited when compared to competitors. 

comparison etoro logo
PROS
CONS
User-friendly web-based platform and mobile app
High minimums for copy trading
Offer trading in 15 cryptocurrencies.
Charge a $25 to buy cryptocurrency
An amazing community of traders 

CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 67% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work, and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

Plus500

Plus500 is a trademark of Plus500 Ltd and was founded in 2008. 

Plus500 is a great option for traders who want to expand and diversify their portfolios. They offer low trading costs and an easy-to-use platform which is great for beginners. 

Plus500 is regulated by the FCA in the UK which makes it a safe option for trading. It also offers negative balance protection and assured stop loss orders. 

A huge downside of Plus500 is that it is not available in the US. 

Plus500 Comparison
PROS
CONS
Offers over 2000 trading instruments
Not available in the US 
User-friendly platforms
Unable to pair the trading platform with other trading tools 
Regulated by FCA

CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 76.4% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

TD Ameritrade

TD Ameritrade is one of the largest online brokers globally. What sets them apart is that they interact with their customers and community via social media such as Twitter and Facebook. This greatly improves their customer service.

TD Ameritrade is great because it offers an amazing range of platforms that are easy to use. The platforms are available online and on mobile. They also offer the thinkorswim platform which caters to active traders. 

TD Ameritrade offers great educational content and is a good option for beginners.

TD Ameritrade Logo
PROS
CONS
Offer free research
Do not offer fractional shares
Zero commissions charged on stocks, options trading, and  ETFs 
Available only in the US
Zero account minimums
Good customer support

Lightspeed

Lightspeed was founded in 2000 and was designed with active, high-volume traders in mind. 

They offer a plethora of platforms and these include Lightspeed Trader, Sterling VolTrader, EZ EMS, and Sterling Trader Pro. However, you should keep in mind that these platforms might have different fee structures. 

A downside of Lightspeed is that they have ridiculously high account minimums that range from $10,000 to $25,000. Their commission schedules are also tiered according to per-share and per-contract commissions which are charged depending on the trading volume.

Lightspeed Logo
PROS
CONS
Traders can route their own orders
High account minimums
Offer a fast order router
Not beginner-friendly 
Great customer service

e-Trade

eTrade is another popular online broker. They have gained a reputation for their professional and easy-to-use platform. The platform appeals to both active traders, and beginners. Beginners can enjoy the vast amount of educational content available.

Like most trading brokers, e-Trade charges $0 commission fees for all stocks, options trading, and ETFs. 

Their trading platform includes a sleek, professional mobile trading app which is great for traders on the go. 

e-trade logo
PROS
CONS
User-friendly trading tools
Their website can be difficult to navigate
Amazing customer support
Offer extensive research and educational content
Rich investment selection

Ninja Traders

Ninja Trades was founded in 2003 and has made a name for themselves for their excellent trading and charting tools. 

For traders with a funded account, the research and charting tools are available free of charge. Their platforms feature real-time analysis and customizable technical indicators. 

Ninja Traders offers their clients access to forex and futures markets. 

What makes them great is that they have partnered with huge brokerage firms like Interactive Brokers and TD Ameritrade. This partnership has allowed them to give their clients access to additional markets like options of futures, equities, and CDFs.

Ninja Trader Logo
PROS
CONS
Amazing charting and analysis tools 
A basic funded account is free but additional fees are required to access advanced features
Offer a paper trading account which is great for practicing and learning without risking cash
A supporting broker is required if you want to trade equities. 
Great educational content

What is Commodity Trading?

A commodity, in simple terms, is a commercial good that is interchangeable with other commercial goods of the same kind. 

Commodities trading used to required vast amounts of time, money, and know-how. Because of this, it was seen as being reserved for professional traders. 

This has changed and today, there are more options available for traders to participate in the commodities market exchange.

Trading commodities has a longer history than stocks and bonds. The rise of many empires has been attributed to their creation of complex trading systems that aided the trading of commodities. 

A commodities broker is usually a firm or an individual that facilitates trades on behalf of traders and investors. This service is charged at a commission and varies from broker to broker. 

Commodities contracts can include options, futures, and other financial derivatives. 

Types of Commodities

Energy

Energy commodities are crude oils, heating oils, gasoline, and natural gasses. Oil prices have increased due to the reduced oil outputs and an increase in demand. 

If you want to invest in energy, you should be aware of the economic downturns. The prevalence of renewable energy plants like wind, solar, and biofuel has also impacted the price of energy commodities. 

Metals

Common metal commodities are silver, gold, copper, and platinum. These commodities are stable and reliable. Investors can turn to metal commodities during times of market volatility. 

Investors could also decide to invest in metal commodities as a hedge in times of inflation. 

Agriculture

Agricultural commodities are soy beans, corn, grain, wheat, rice, coffee, cocoa, sugar, and coffee. 

You should keep in mind that when investing in agricultural commodities, that grains can be volatile during summer. These commodities are also influenced by weather-related transitions. 

Livestock and Meat

Livestock and Meat commodities are pork bellies, lean hog, feeder cattle, and live cattle. 

Investing in Commodities 

Here are a few methods for investing in commodities

Futures

One of the common methods to invest in commodities is through futures contracts. A futures contract is a legal agreement to buy and sell a contract that has underlying commodities attached to it. This is done at a predetermined price and a predetermined date. 

Generally, there are two kinds of investors that invest in commodities through futures contracts. There are commercial traders and institutional traders. 

An advantage of this method of investment is that analysis is much easier because of the pure play on the underlying commodity. With this method, you also have the potential to make great profits. 

Stocks

Another method of investing in commodities is to invest in the stock of companies that are related to the commodity you wish to invest in, in some way. Examples of this are investing in the stock of oil companies or agricultural companies. 

A benefit of this method is that stocks are less volatile to price swings than futures contracts. Stocks are also easier to hold, trade, and track. 

However, you should do your research before investing in companies.

ETFs

An additional option for investors wanting to invest in commodities is through exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and exchange-traded notes (ETNs). ETFs and ETNs are similar to trading stocks. 

A benefit of this is that you can earn a profit from the fluctuations of the commodity prices without having to invest in futures contracts.  

An additional benefit of this method is that there are no management or redemption fees with ETFs and ETNs because they trade like stocks. 

Commodity ETFs can use futures contracts to track the price of a particular commodity. 

Keep in mind that not all commodities have ETNs and ETFs associated with them. 

Mutual and Index Funds

Mutual funds cannot be used to directly invest in commodities. However, it can be invested in stocks of companies that are related to commodities industries like energy companies. 

Much like stocks, mutual and index funds are influenced by the fluctuating prices of commodities, general stock market fluctuations, and company factors. 

A benefit of using this method is that you get professional money management, added diversification of your portfolio, and increased liquidity. 

But, keep in mind that management fees can be high. 

Commodity Pools and Managed Futures

Commodity pool operators (CPO) are people or partnerships that pools money from investors intending to invest the money in futures or options. The CPOs will regularly distribute account statements and annual financial reports to their investors. 

A benefit of using this method is that investors receive professional advice from a commodity trading advisor  (CTA) that is employed by the CPO.  

Pooled structures also have the benefit of more money and increased opportunities for a manager to invest. 

Picking a Commodities Broker

Safety and Regulation

This is one of the most important factors you should consider when choosing a commodities broker. Brokers are regulated by financial organizations or institutions to protect customers. 

Regulators also decide which countries brokers can operate in. 

It is important to check whether a broker is regulated to ensure the safety of your money and assets. 

Fees & Commissions

Fee structures and commissions vary from broker to broker. This information should be readily provided on the broker’s website. It is important to go through the fee structures so that you know what you’re getting yourself into. 

Additional fees that brokers can charge are inactivity fees and account minimums. These fees can also vary from asset class to asset class.

Customer Support

Whether you’re a newbie or an advanced trader, the customer support a broker offers should be a priority. 

You should check the kind of customer support a broker offers. Do they offer email support, live chat, or phone support? It is also important to check how responsive the customer support services are. 

Education and Research

This is an important aspect to consider when choosing a broker. Whether you’re a beginner or a professional trader, you should go for a broker that has a robust selection of educational content, research content, and research tools. 

If you’re a beginner, you might want to invest in a broker that offers a paper trading account so that you can get a feel for the platform and trading. 

Educational content and research are also important when developing a trading strategy. 

Trading Platforms

The broker you choose should provide a trading platform that is easy to use and that offers a plethora of trading tools. Check for key features like charting, platform design, and technical analysis tools. 

You should also check if their platform offers a mobile app or in-browser mobile trading. This is essential if you have an active lifestyle

Types of Commodities Brokers 

There are different kinds of commodities brokers. Here are the most common kinds of commodities brokers

Futures Commissions Merchant (FCM)

An FCM is an individual or firm that accepts and solicits orders for commodities contracts on the exchange on behalf of clients. They also hold client funds to margin. FCM’s operate similarly to a securities broker-dealer. 

Floor Broker/Trader

A floor broker or floor trader trades commodities contracts on the floor of a commodities exchange. They generally act as a broker and conduct trades on behalf of clients. 

Floor brokers can also act on their accounts or the account of an employer. 

Introducing Broker (IB)

An IB is an individual or a firm that accepts or solicits orders for commodity contracts on an exchange. However, unlike an FCM, the IB does not hold customer funds to margin. 

Commodity Pool Operator (CPO)

A CPO is a firm or individual that pools resources from multiple investors and manages this as advised by a CTA. A CPO is similar to a mutual fund. 

Commodity Trading Advisor (CTA)

A CTA is a firm or individual that advises traders on trading commodities contracts for a fee. They can act as advisors for community pools or traders. Like an IB, a CTA does not hold margins funds for customers. 

CTA’s can also act with power of attorney over client accounts on behalf of the client and according to the client’s trading objectives. 

Registered Commodity Representative (RCR)

An RCR is an employee, officer, or partner at an IB, CTA, CPO, or FCM. They are registered and licensed to do work for the FCM, IB, CPO, or CTA. 

Commodity Exchanges 

Commodity brokers can trade commodities on different exchanges which are specialized in trading different commodity types. 

Commodity exchanges include the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) and the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX). These exchanges trade in agricultural commodities and energy commodities. 

The Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) trades in energy commodities. 

Principles of supply and demand are what drive commodity exchanges. Changes in supply impact the demand. This can also impact, and cause, price fluctuations of the commodities. 

You should keep in mind that the different commodities are impacted by different things. For example, agricultural commodities are impacted by weather changes. With livestock and meat commodities, illnesses in animals can impact supply. 

Global economic development and advances in technology also impact and causes price fluctuations. An example of this is the emergence of India and China as players in manufacturing which increased the demand for metal commodities.